Hidden Brain · Ideas & Essays · November 2026
He was describing a field study at re-employment centers, where job seekers wrote either a story of being believed in or a story of defying low expectations. The underdog story protected their confidence and was followed by more job offers.
…those low expectations and ended up being successful. So, we had people think of stories like this from their lives, and we also had them reflect on those experiences: what lessons did they learn, what themes came up from it, and how they would apply that to their own job search going forward.
And what did you find?
So, what we found was really interesting. So, we did these one-hour-long interventions, these workshops. And what we found is that when people had the underdog narrative, what it did is it buffered them against experiences of adversity in the form of discrimination. And what ended up happening is that this adversity didn't impact themselves as negatively. So, it actually buffered them against their drop-in self-confidence in the job search. And weeks later, what we found is that these people were more likely to get jobs, essentially.
In other words, triggering the underdog effect almost was inoculating people against the effects of discrimination.
Yeah, absolutely. And that's, you know, we did this in the field in these re-employment centers, and then we did some follow-up studies to better understand what was going on. And we saw this consistent finding across different settings.
You also have looked at some fascinating work when people are selected for something, but then they later discover that they were not the first choice. Tell me about this work, Samir.