Hidden Brain · Ideas & Essays · November 2026
He was explaining a study that tried to reconcile the "underdog effect" with older research on self-fulfilling prophecies. Being doubted pushed people to perform better only when the doubter wasn't seen as credible, which is his answer to why criticism sometimes crushes us and sometimes fires us up.
…lab, if you're coming into one of my studies, researchers are giving you this assessment, but they don't know much more about you than that. So there was something different here about the credibility of who holds the expectations. And that might be the key to understanding why I was finding these
…basically is that when the criticism comes from somebody with high credibility, it might have more of a self-fulfilling prophecy effect. But when the criticism comes from someone who potentially has low credibility, it might prompt us to fight back, to disagree with it, to find contrary evidence.
Yeah, that's exactly right. And that's what I tried to do in the last study that I had. So in addition to giving people different sets of expectations, whether they were seen as likely to succeed or less likely to succeed, I varied the credibility of the observers. You know, how accurate were they as forecasters and whether they were seen as experts or not. And what ended up happening is that I found that it was only when those observers were seen as less credible by the participant that it translated to higher performance. One example of this was Allie Raisman, who is a gymnast for the U.S. Olympic team. After the 2012 Olympics, she had just missed out on placing on the podium. And, you know, for gymnasts, you're often thought your careers are rather short. Gymnasts retire rather early in their lives. But Allie Raisman returned for the 2016 Olympics. It was funnily enough, critics started calling her the grandma…
Being dismissed can make us curl up into a ball and give up. But sometimes being dismissed makes us rise to the occasion and stand up and fight. Underdogs who have a chip on their shoulder don't perform well in spite of being doubted, they perform well because they've been doubted. When we come…
Yeah, so Jalen Brunson was a player who actually played for Villanova and won a national championship with them as a basketball player. And then he was drafted by the Dallas Mavericks, but was, you know, kind of like Tom Brady drafted in the second round, not sixth round at least. But there were…
Now, of course, we're recording this interview a few weeks after the Knicks won the NBA championship with Jalen Brunson at the helm.