CM Chris McGuire On The Lawfare Podcast

“The gap in this element, I think, is the most significant one, which is that it applies everywhere but inside the United States. So right now my big concern is until that is fixed, every Chinese company that was previously renting access from data centers in Johor, Malaysia is going to instead rent them from Northern Virginia. … Northern Virginia is going to become the Chinese AI computing hub of the world until this is closed.”

The Lawfare Podcast · Policy · November 2026

“The gap in this element, I think, is the most significant one, which is that it applies everywhere but inside the United States. So right now my big concern is until that is fixed, every Chinese company that was previously renting access from data centers in Johor, Malaysia is going to instead rent them from Northern Virginia. … Northern Virginia is going to become the Chinese AI computing hub of the world until this is closed.” — Chris McGuire, The Lawfare Podcast

Context

Asked what this week's new Commerce rule on remote chip access fixes, McGuire praises it but points to a big hole: it doesn't cover data centers inside the US.

Transcript

The Lawfare Podcast Around 29:31 into the episode
Chris McGuire

…actually, we should like in the areas where we have, where we actually do have a big lead, where we are really, really good at this, we should be seizing that and using that to our advantage. And that's the whole thesis of this rather than just giving away the store. And I continue to believe that.

Julia Curlee

…center of this scandal and limiting Chinese abilities to rent their chips remotely. Can you talk about what this fixes and also address the fact that this rule leaves out the Gulf states, including UAE, which has been the intention for sort of this end run around our export controls for some time?

Chris McGuire

Yeah. So what the rule does is actually there were 46 countries previously that were subject to licenses for AI chips. Actually, those did include the UAE and the Gulf states already. So there is some concern specifically about the UAE because the UAE was actually moved out of that category. It originally did include the UAE, and then the UAE was moved out of the category, which is like mind-blowing to me. And there's no reason why we should want less visibility into AI chip sales in the UAE, even if you want, even if you want to permit them, you should still want to know about them. And previously, we had, you know, we basically had the leverage and the veto power and also just, if nothing else, the ability to see them. And we gave that away. So that's a whole separate issue we should talk about. But generally, or someone else should talk about it. But generally, you see there's these 46 countries. And then what they did is they added to the rule five. They added Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, and Brazil. So the Southeast Asian countries that are known to be the big smuggling hubs, Brazil is building a big data center for Byte Dance, their biggest data center outside China is being built in Brazil.…

Julia Curlee

I do love the idea that we're closing the Malaysia loophole, but the one in Northern Virginia across the river from me is still available. It's

Chris McGuire

funny because people forget about America in this, partly because we use export controls to regulate it, right? But the problem is export controls only get exports. They don't get things here. Now, there are authorities that we could use to get at this. There's namely within export control…

Julia Curlee

So, Chris, right now, Congress is weighing four chips bills that would ride on this year's NDAA, the defense authorization bill. But Secretary Besant has said that no law is required at this point. What do you think is the top priority for this Congress to get it done before they break for the new…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Lawfare Podcast