Hidden Brain · Ideas & Essays · October 2026
The guest, addressed as Kate by the host, was describing how people reacted after she wrote publicly about her cancer diagnosis. She said most of the responses tried to "pour certainty over pain" by supplying an explanation.
…I mean, I will never forget the like the love in some of these very heartbreaking notes about like, Kate, I have wasted my own life. I wish, I wish there was a way that we could, that, that you could take a little of mine and I could take a little of yours and we could make a world that is fair.
I understand that at one point, one of your neighbors stopped by your house to share a sentiment with your husband.
Yes, I had a neighbor stop by, and she told my husband, Well, everything happens for a reason. And he immediately just said, I'd love to hear it. I'd love to hear the reason my wife is dying.
The responses to your illness were so consistent that you eventually divided them into different categories. And you describe these groups of people as the minimizers, the teachers, and the solutions people. Unpack those terms for me, Kate.
Well, the minimizers are pretty sure that whatever is going on, it's probably not as bad as I think it is. So these were at least, any sentence starting with at least is typically a minimizer. At least you're at a good hospital. I remember when we were in the earliest days, really struggling with…
So I'm hearing a common thread in all of these responses. People are trying in some ways to preserve a sense of loss. And order around an event that was frightening in its randomness. Does that sound right to you as an explanation for these different veins of feedback and advice?