The Lawfare Podcast · Policy · November 2026
McGuire describes the regulatory limbo before this week's new rule: an older licensing rule stayed on the books while the government said it wouldn't enforce it, so for about two years nobody could say what the law was.
…And it was something that I know we thought you said that, okay, we will get to it, but we didn't do enough. And then as AI has really exploded over the last two years, there's been basically a complete pause on this effort of using export controls to increase U.S. advantages in AI until Monday.
…Do you think that it would have caught them with the old rules? It would have basically prevented this all from happening. And why didn't the current Commerce Department catch the red flags that this was an obvious cutout for China to either use overseas or to actually import it into China?
Yeah, it definitely would have been captured. I think that it would have just been very clear that basically every shipment to Malaysia would have required a license unless it was to a trusted U.S. company that was on the list. Obviously, U.S. hyperscalers would have been fine. But the idea was like, unless the government had already approved you to say like, yeah, we trust you not to use AI chips in bad ways. It would have required a license. So, I mean, I suppose that someone could have sent them a billion dollars of chips just completely covertly, but like that kind of thing does get caught. Like, and to be clear, like no one is under any impression that it's possible to prevent China from getting every single AI chip in the world. Like, yes, obviously, there's going to be onesie twosies that get smuggled, but part of the thesis here is you need a lot of these. Like, you need very large numbers of them. You need tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, billions of dollars worth of chips to really compete at the frontier. And regulations that say you can't do this to untrusted companies, I think, would have…
Yeah, I absolutely agree. I mean, I, doing my own work on this, have noted there were at least six opportunities since 2025 that the administration could have done something on this, that there was a point of action. And at no point did they actually take a step. And of course, the president was…
Yeah. Well, sorry, your last question, there is not a good answer for why they have not blacklisted Megaspeed. I will say I think the actions that were taken on Monday probably do prevent any future AI chip sales to Megaspeed or its subsidiaries, at least directly. So that's good. That said, just…
Yeah, absolutely. And you both, we both worked in government. And the idea that the president, according to the same reports, would have ordered this multiple times and yet it wasn't followed through on suggests something is here that we're not quite seeing. So presumably more will come out of this…