WB Winnona Bernsen On The Lawfare Podcast

“It's not like you can kind of waltz up to the NSA and go, hi, I have this fun bug. Would you like to buy it? And so if you don't know a government customer, you'll probably want to find a middleman, which is where things get a little bit more sketchy because you don't necessarily know who will end up using your zero day, especially when middlemen sell to other middlemen.”

The Lawfare Podcast · Policy · November 2026

“It's not like you can kind of waltz up to the NSA and go, hi, I have this fun bug. Would you like to buy it? And so if you don't know a government customer, you'll probably want to find a middleman, which is where things get a little bit more sketchy because you don't necessarily know who will end up using your zero day, especially when middlemen sell to other middlemen.” — Winnona Bernsen, The Lawfare Podcast

Context

Asked what it takes to make and sell a zero-day exploit, the cyber policy researcher says building one takes months of skilled work, and that selling one is a separate and murkier problem. The episode is an archive rebroadcast of a 2025 interview.

Transcript

The Lawfare Podcast Around 13:09 into the episode
Speaker 1

…you also have these huge brokers and marketplaces. So firms that act as middlemen to go get a zero day and then sell it onward to either another middleman or a government. And then underpinning all of this are smaller subcontractors, startups, and individual hackers. It's a really robust ecosystem.

Justin Sherman

What does it take for a business to succeed in this area and to effectively create and then sell one of these zero-day exploits you're talking about?

Speaker 1

…or every iPhone all the way back to 2014? And so that process in itself of creating a zero day or an O Day, as some people call it, can take, at least nowadays in modern software, between six to 18 months to go from nothing to something marketable. Now, selling is actually where it gets even more complicated. Now that you have an O Day, you need to know a customer or get in touch with one. And it's not like you can kind of waltz up to the NSA and go, hi, I have this fun bug. Would you like to buy it? And so if you don't know a government customer, you'll probably want to find a middleman, which is where things get a little bit more sketchy because you don't necessarily know who will end up using your zero day, especially when middlemen sell to other middlemen. And so you get this weird, murky industry where there's markups and bugs that are going for crazy prices. And then you have this lack of trust on the consumer side.

Justin Sherman

To deviate for just a second, Winona, now that you mention it, you highlighted some, I found this fascinating in the report, specific numbers on what that markup can look like from the original developer of a zero-day exploit to the middleman reseller to the end buyer. Can you just tell us what…

Speaker 1

Sure. So with the caveat that this industry is super murky and what I've reported on is really only likely a sliver of what the global market looks like. I've had interviews where people have said it's anywhere from double to triple to 10x the markup. The quote that I've put into the report…

Justin Sherman

I just found that fascinating. And I think, as we're saying, if we think of these as highly valuable, as you mentioned, the idea that governments are paying so much, not necessarily or inherently because it's valuable and difficult to procure per se, but because of a markup is really, really…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Lawfare Podcast