Robert Wright

Things Robert Says on Podcasts

Author and podcaster who writes about evolution, psychology, religion and the prospects for global cooperation, now with a focus on AI and how to avert catastrophe. Wrote The Moral Animal, Nonzero, The Evolution of God and Why Buddhism Is True, and co-founded Bloggingheads.tv in 2005. Hosts the Nonzero podcast and publishes the Nonzero Newsletter on Substack, and appears as a host or guest on Small Potatoes, Doom Debates!, American Prestige and The Cognitive Revolution.

Where to Find Them

Robert Wright hosts and writes Robert Wright's Nonzero , hosts and writes NonZero Newsletter , hosts Doom Debates! , hosts Small Potatoes , writes Understanding AI , writes The Fifth Column , writes Conspicuous Cognition , writes The Fifth Column (A Podcast) and writes Free the People . They have also been a guest on American Prestige (5 times) , The Cognitive Revolution" | AI Builders, Researchers, and Live Player Analysis (4 times) , On the Media (3 times) , Very Bad Wizards (3 times) , 80,000 Hours Podcast (2 times) , EconTalk (2 times) , Glenn Loury (2 times) , Conversations with Coleman (2 times) , Sinica (2 times) , The Lawfare Podcast , The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition , Tangentially Speaking with Chris Ryan , Plain English with Derek Thompson , Executive Functions Chat , The Most Interesting Thing in AI , The Excerpt , The Ezra Klein Show , Scott Horton Show - Just the Interviews , Scaling Laws and Beyond The Prompt - How to use AI in your company .

Recently: “Israel and America after Their Elections (Robert Wright and Daniel Levy)” on NonZero Newsletter (November 2026); “Israel and America after Their Elections (Robert Wright and Daniel Levy)” on Robert Wright's Nonzero (November 2026); “Jensen Huang and the Deep State (Robert Wright, Liron Shapira, and Chinese mystery guest)” on NonZero Newsletter (November 2026); “Jensen Huang and the Deep State (Robert Wright, Liron Shapira, and Chinese mystery guest)” on Robert Wright's Nonzero (November 2026); “Jensen Huang Resigns, RSI Coming in 2027 — with Robert Wright” on Doom Debates! (November 2026); “Whatever You Might Think About AI, You Must Feel Awe: Pulitzer Finalist Robert Wright on “The God Test”” on Beyond The Prompt - How to use AI in your company (November 2026).

What They Said

“I don't think it's quite tulips. The AI per se is very real, and there's a ton of potential economic value there. But anybody who thinks they have a very clear idea of where the value is going to accrue in the long run, which specific companies, chip companies, AI companies, is more confident of their judgment than I am of mine.” — Robert Wright, Doom Debates!

Liron Shapira had noted Nvidia's stock fall and Google's rise. Robert Wright says the emotion in AI assets is high but the technology is real, and he won't pick winners.

Doom Debates! · 2026-11-13 Permalink → Listen →
Doom Debates! Around 17:23 into the episode
Robert Wright

…But I digress. The models have something to do with it. I don't know. I don't know whether there's, I mean, look, you know, people who sell their NVIDIA stock, but still believe in AI broadly, it got to go somewhere. Google's a plausible place. It could have to do with that. Yeah, you know what?

Liron Shapira

…business. I think it's undervalued, but it's not 10 to 20%. It's like 5% since the low of earlier this month. So, you know, I don't want to read the tea leaves too hard here. But, you know, at least it's a positive sign. I feel like that's maybe the positiveness of it is correlated, but who knows?

Robert Wright

Yeah, and I suspect, I mean, as for the fall in NVIDIA's stock price, I think there's a lot of emotion running through the whole market for AI assets. I mean, on the market, it's like, you know, I don't think it's quite, it's not tulips, you know, the famous example of a run-up. The AI per se is very real, and there's a ton of potential economic value there. But I think anybody who thinks they have a very clear idea of where the value is going to accrue in the long run, which specific companies, chip companies, AI companies, is more confident of their judgment than I am of mine.

Liron Shapira

I know where it's going to accrue. I think I know where it's going to accrue. My hypothesis is everywhere because I think that we're just going to be supply constrained for the next however many years, five years, 10 years. I think the entire, this is in a non-doom scenario, by the way, which I…

Robert Wright

building. Yeah. And I think the risk for people who are heavily invested in AI is that, first of all, I agree with you. Let's assume everything goes well and this technology isn't like massively destabilizing, which I think it will be if it's not governed carefully and ultimately governed…

Liron Shapira

Yep. All right. Yeah. So that's, you know, that's a developing story. There's so many threads to it. It'll be interesting to see what comes out about the Chinese spying. It'll be interesting to see what Jensen is going to do next. Is he going to try to pull a Sam Altman and seize power again? Is he…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“I would guess the Jensen thing helps Anthropic's IPO. We will see tighter enforcement of existing chip restrictions, quite plausibly a whole new regulation on the deployment of chips to clouds that can be rented by Chinese companies. That makes chips more abundant and therefore cheaper for American companies, and presumably slows down China's open source stuff, which slows the commoditization of Anthropic's current revenue stream.” — Robert Wright, Doom Debates!

Robert Wright asked whether Jensen Huang's fall would affect Anthropic's upcoming IPO, then answered himself. He frames Dario Amodei's long-running China hawkishness as consistent with Anthropic's commercial interest.

Doom Debates! · 2026-11-13 Permalink → Listen →
Doom Debates! Around 47:21 into the episode
Robert Wright

…Anthropic's IPO? It's not inconceivable that it could adversely affect it. I guess I haven't thought it through at all. I'm just asking the question. I'm not talking finance here. Yeah, because the IPO could happen as early as like, I think, a week from now or something. I don't know. Yeah, yeah,

Liron Shapira

…that needs to come online just to serve current models, right? I think that they can make trillions per year in revenue serving current models. That's what I think. And I'm speaking as somebody who's personally paying like $1,000 a day for AI and for my corporate use right now because it's super

Robert Wright

useful. Yeah, by the way, my unfold disclosure is a few years ago when the LLM thing hit, I just thought, well, you know, I bought some stock and put it in my, in my SEP IRA in, I don't know, Google, Microsoft, probably Apple, Amazon, Meta, maybe somebody else. I think since then I sold a little meta at one point where it looked like Zuckerberg was totally out of the rate, but I basically don't touch it. I'm definitely calling for things that I think in the short term would hurt the stock value. I do think in the long run, stability is good. So I guess in a way, I'm talking my book, my long run book, because I think, you know, a pause would be more likely to lead to a stable future one, two, three years down the road, whatever. Anyway, that's my full disclosure. Now, remind me where you think I was heading before. Oh, I know what I wanted to say. Like, I would guess there was in a way some risk that the NVIDIA thing could hurt Anthropic, just in the sense that, you know, there's nervousness about the AI trade and the, you know, the various like the neo clouds and blah, blah, blah. And you can imagine. The NVIDIA thing, when it hurt NVIDIA stock, having triggered some kind of cascade of panic. Last time I checked…

Liron Shapira

All right. Yeah, you know, maybe we'll see. We'll see if you're correct very shortly. All right. I think you are similar to me pro this idea of an AI treaty between the U.S. and China. So maybe you also feel good about this March for an AI treaty, Saturday, November 14th, AITreatyMarch.org…

Robert Wright

I encourage people to turn out. I also think a pause at a surely national level would make sense at this point, would not hurt Anthropic and OpenAI would not lead China to catch up rapidly. I've actually written a piece about that. I hope it'll be published at some venue near you, possibly my…

Liron Shapira

I should say: San Francisco, Washington, D.C., New York, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, Montreal, Toronto, Vancouver, Paris, Marseille, Berlin, Atlanta. Whoa, whoa, whoa. Okay, Atlanta's unconfirmed. All right, but that's still a lot of cities. Okay. I think the anti-AI or the AI pacing…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“I would challenge anyone who doesn't think there are going to be big job impacts to tell me what economically valuable work humans do that you think AI will never be able to do. Is there a desk job? Is there an office job that fits that description? I don't think so. If you think the robotics thing is going to be big, there will be a diminishing number of physical jobs.” — Robert Wright, Beyond The Prompt - How to use AI in your company

A host asked for a concrete picture of what it looks like when AI goes right. Wright sketches good outcomes such as cured diseases and cheap tutors, then says people will probably have the option, or the necessity, of not working.

Beyond The Prompt - How to use AI in your company · 2026-11-11 Permalink → Listen →
Beyond The Prompt - How to use AI in your company Around 19:30 into the episode
Robert Wright

on the situation. Those men who are overestimating the attractiveness of the women. I mean, men over also overestimate in many situations how attractive the woman is finding them.

Speaker 3

…of what does it actually mean when this goes right outside like UBI, which in my point of view is just taking agency around away from people, which is not necessarily a good thing either. Do you have like a version where he goes like, okay, this actually played out? This was the bright spot.

Robert Wright

I have a way to make it as good as it can be. In other words, like I outline, like, yeah, we need to start, you know, coordinating internationally and doing these things and looking at these questions. I don't think we should put all our faith in alignment, although, and so on. So I have a path I sketch in terms of what it looks like. I mean, I have a chapter on AI hell and AI heaven. I look at Dario Amade, the CEO of Anthropic's vision of what kind of AI heaven would look like. And I note, you know, some complications there. But I mean, look, there's some obvious, they're just good things you can point to now. Like, that's great that I can go out in my front yard and find out about this plant. And from my point of view, do something that otherwise I guess I'd have to pay some expert to come tell me or do a lot more research. The diseases, I think, will get cured via AI, can get cured. There will be huge scientific progress that can be put to the good. It is already easier for people who in the world who previously had just no access to good education to get, in effect, you know, personal tutors at a pretty low cost. So there's all kinds of good things…

Speaker 2

Bob, one question that I have had on my mind, a book that comes to my mind often is Vonnegut's Player Piano. I was actually just talking with a friend about it the other day. And if you both don't know the premise, the short of it is Vonnegut imagines a future where engineers are a small percentage…

Robert Wright

Well, I'm sure you can point to successful retirement stories, you know, but it's very challenging. So, I mean, if you just look at humans who retire, that's a relevant subset. I don't think it's exactly analogous. Some people do it successfully. I mean, I think one thing that will that may happen…

Speaker 2

hoc, maybe, or it's not a deliberate thing. But I just

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“As of a year ago, I had this theory when people were saying, where's the productivity growth? … But I had this theory that what was actually happening was that the workers who had figured out how to use AI weren't telling their bosses. They were just spending their day at the beach, right? And so they're still getting as much money as they were to do the same amount of work they were doing. So the productivity growth doesn't show up unless you count beach time.” — Robert Wright, Doom Debates!

Robert Wright is wrapping up the conversation with one last question for Liron, about why AI's effect on the economy was not yet visible in productivity statistics. He offers this as a theory he held a year earlier and then asks whether it still applies. Liron answers by pointing to fast revenue growth at early-stage startups.

Doom Debates! · 2026-10-31 Permalink → Listen →
Doom Debates! Around 1:13:01 into the episode
Robert Wright

good. Yeah, even there. Anyway, how many human hours of work two years ago would it have taken to do that $1,000 worth of work, roughly?

Liron Shapira

…like shoot off a little thought, switch context, switch back context, see the answer. And these are just questions that normally we just, we just wouldn't have the answer. We wouldn't iterate, right? So there's this, there's all this iteration happen happening rapidly that just didn't used to be a

Robert Wright

thing. Okay. I've got what we call in the business a hard out at the half hour mark, but I have one more question for you. So I had this, like as of a year ago, I had this theory when people were saying, where's the productivity growth? Well, first of all, that always takes time. I mean, it took a long time, you know, with the original kind of PC revolution, then the online PC revolution and so on. That was kind of slow to accumulate. But I had this theory that what was actually happening was that the workers who had figured out how to use AI weren't telling their bosses. They were just spending their day at the beach, right? And so they're still getting as much money as they were to do the same amount of work they were doing. So the productivity growth doesn't show up unless you count beach time. Do you think that is still happening to some extent? Or I've got to think the companies are wising up. But what is your sense for that?

Liron Shapira

Yeah, it's an interesting question. You know, what's going on with AI productivity growth? So for one thing, I actually think the best place to see the proof of AI productivity growth is in the early stage startup market. If you listen to Y Combinator, see what they're saying. And if you listen to…

Robert Wright

I agree. Yeah, I don't know. Edzitron, I'm not sure. There was a very

Liron Shapira

interesting stat, although circling back to the Anthropic IPO discussion, right? The S1, and you mentioned Edzitron. I think the number one takeaway here is that this is the final nail in the coffin of the Edzitron camp, right? This idea that, like, look, sure, Anthropic is making tokens, but…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“You could say the Boeing Corporation is a superintelligence. No one human could know how to build an airliner, but the Boeing Corporation is an information processing system that collectively knows that. And from a sufficient distance, it just looks like a giant brain.” — Robert Wright, Doom Debates!

Wright was explaining why even well-informed people have trouble picturing superintelligence. His answer is that it may not be one very smart model but many pretty smart ones working together, the way a company knows things none of its employees do. He goes on to apply the same idea to swarms of AI agents.

Doom Debates! · 2026-10-02 Permalink → Listen →
Doom Debates! Around 51:44 into the episode
Liron Shapira

been compared in the past when I was even nerdier than I am now. I've been compared in the past to Sheldon from, you know, the Big Bang Theory.

Speaker 2

Okay, that's a that's a that

Robert Wright

…there's another thing going on here, uh, in terms of people having trouble, maybe still, including, I, you know, I'd say smart, well-informed people, imagining pretty well-informed people, imagining what's coming. And it was so well illustrated by the Open AI breakout. It's like, you know, when you ask what is super intelligence, I've said this before, but one way to say it is like, you know, you could say the Boeing Corporation is a superintelligence. No one human could know how to build an airliner, but the Boeing Corporation is an information processing system that collectively knows that. And from a sufficient distance, it just looks like a giant brain. And when you put a lot of pretty smart brains together, like the people who work at Boeing, you get pretty amazing shit that no single brain could do. And it's the same way with agent swarms, you know? And, you know, as I've said, it's Like, well, what's the difference between AGI and superintelligence? Well, maybe just a difference between an LLM and the agent swarm it can sponsor, right? I…

Liron Shapira

Yeah, so let's help the people with their ontology, right? Because the same way that we would have liked people to realize that the chatbots aren't going to look like chatbots, right? So today they look like agents, but the agents still stay in your computer and the agents still have an off-button…

Robert Wright

Yeah, I think right now, you know, it's great that the discourse has moved to a point where people are demanding some kind of governmental action. But it's true that you're hearing things like build an off switch and make super intelligence illegal. I'm not saying those are bad things. It might be…

Liron Shapira

Yeah, I want to help people understand that it's, you know, the type of thing it is, right? It's not chatbot and it's not exactly even agent. I mean, in a technical sense, it still is because agent just means outcome steering entity. So it is still going to be a lot of fun. It has a goal,

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“A chatbot is like somebody you visit in the hospital who can't get out of bed. They can talk to you, they can draw pictures, but they're not going to get up and change the thermostat, much less stage a coup and take over the hospital. But once you're talking about agents, you're just in a whole different world.” — Robert Wright, Doom Debates!

Wright and Liron Shapira were discussing why public attitudes to AI risk have shifted. Shapira had argued that people used to file AI under "it's just text", and that agents changed the mental category. Wright says this is the image he uses in his book.

Doom Debates! · 2026-10-02 Permalink → Listen →
Doom Debates! Around 47:12 into the episode
Robert Wright

…things like, oh, God, should I sacrifice for the group? My gut says no. I mean, their thought traces, you know, the chain of thought text was saying things like that. And I think that freaked people. The whole idea of an agent swarm, like people hadn't thought, like, wait, a thousand AIs? That's

Liron Shapira

…could already show us that even the chatbots were marching toward this end game. So that's why we're able to see this progression earlier. So, yeah, we don't think in the same ontology, but the average American is now seeing things in a more accurate ontology and they're getting properly scared.

Robert Wright

Right. I mean, the way I put it in my book is a chatbot is like somebody you visit in the hospital who can't get out of bed. They can talk to you, they can draw pictures, but they're not going to get up and change the thermostat, much less like stage a coup and take over the hospital. But once you're talking about agents, you're just in a whole different world. And, you know, that is now vivid. And, you know, it's funny we're talking about like as if like the various atmospherics have changed attitudes. And that's true, like the atmospheric of reading what these agents are kind of quote thinking or the atmospherics of somebody resigning from Anthropic. But also what people are seeing is like the underlying reality is being exposed. This stuff is as powerful and unpredictable and hard to control as we saw. I mean, granted, OpenAI had taken the safeguards off for purposes of evaluation and so on. Still, the creativity demonstrated was a profound surprise to OpenAI. And in general, as we said earlier, more and more people are just acknowledging like this alignment thing. Well, we don't have…

Liron Shapira

I think there's another reason why the average person has, I claim, good intuitions about the scariness of intelligence. You know, when we're in the tech industry, when we're among smart people, you know, we both have smart audiences. We both hang out with smart people. And when you're an…

Robert Wright

I had forgotten about the word. What cartoon was Poindexter in? There was an actual cartoon, right? Big glass. I don't know where that's. Do you consider yourself a Poindexter, by the

Liron Shapira

way? Do I? I mean, in terms of having above-average IQ, sure.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

Collections They Appear In