Kevin Roose

Things Kevin Says on Podcasts

Technology journalist and author covering AI and the labs building it, and a former New York Times technology columnist. His books are The Unlikely Disciple, Young Money, Futureproof and The AGI Chronicles, out in October 2026. Won the 2018 Gerald Loeb Award for breaking news. Co-hosted Hard Fork with Casey Newton at the New York Times until its final episode in September 2026, and launches Machine Gods with Newton in partnership with NPR. Appears as a guest on The Daily, Plain English with Derek Thompson, Pivot and The Ezra Klein Show.

Where to Find Them

Kevin Roose hosts Hard Fork (NYT) , hosts The Daily (NYT) , writes Kevin Roose , writes Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast , writes jasmi.news | @jasmine and hosts Short Wave . They have also been a guest on Plain English with Derek Thompson (11 times) , Recode Media (5 times) , Big Technology (3 times) , Pivot (Kara Swisher & Scott Galloway) (3 times) , Pioneers of AI (2 times) , The Rundown (2 times) , The Ezra Klein Show (2 times) , The Last Invention (2 times) , Decoder with Nilay Patel (2 times) , AI & I (2 times) , For Humanity: An AI Risk Podcast , The New Yorker Radio Hour , The Gray Area with Sean Illing , The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway , What Next | Daily News and Analysis , Money, Power, Politics with Stephanie Ruhle , ChinaTalk , Digital Disruption with Geoff Nielson , The Vergecast , Uncanny Valley | WIRED , AI For Humans: Weekly AI News, Tools & Trends , Making Sense with Sam Harris , CoinDesk Podcast Network , Science Quickly , On with Kara Swisher , The TED AI Show , Reasonably Optimistic , Slate Money , Sam Harris , What Next: TBD | Tech, power, and the future , Mixed Signals from Semafor Media , TechStuff , The Rich Roll Podcast and Search Engine . They also write for Kevin Roose on Substack.

Recently: “Kevin Roose on a Year of A.I. Boom and Backlash” on The New Yorker Radio Hour (November 2026); “The Future of Capitalism Now Centers on AI, with Kevin Roose” on Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast (November 2026); “The Jensen Huang Affair” on Hard Fork (NYT) (November 2026); “What scares the people making AI” on Science Quickly (November 2026); “The Inside Story of the 50 Who Built Modern AI With Kevin Roose” on AI & I (November 2026); “OpenAI whistleblowers on the fight over AI safety | Machine Gods” on Short Wave (November 2026).

What They Said

“We require pharmaceutical companies to test their drugs before selling them to the public. We should require AI companies to test their models before offering them to the public.” — Kevin Roose, AI & I

Asked what has to happen for AI regulation to work, Roose says federal action is unlikely until something bad happens. He proposes an industry certification program as the first step: safety testing for things like autonomous cyberattacks and novel bioweapons before a model is deployed.

AI & I · 2026-11-04 Permalink → Listen →
AI & I Around 11:22 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…we can do it. We have navigated hard challenges in our history. This is maybe one of the hardest, but I think we can do it. And I don't think anything is set in stone or predestined. And I think the choices that we make right now matter a lot in terms of how the next few years or few decades go.

Natalia Quintero

…to be some level of regulation after something went wrong. And, you know, we're there, right? A few things have gone wrong. We've had the Hugging Face incident and a number of other cybersecurity concerns. How do you see this going right, right? Like what needs to happen for us to course correct?

Kevin Roose

…some kind of industry standard, right? Some kind of certification program where, in order to release your model or in order to deploy your model to the public, you have to kind of subject it to some standard safety testing to make sure it's not going to go out there and do autonomous cyber attacks or be weaponized to create novel bioweapons. That seems like basic table stakes to me. You know, we require pharmaceutical companies to test their drugs before selling them to the public. We should require AI companies to test their models before offering them to the public. So that's a first step. From there, I think you probably need some kind of a coordination mechanism for slowing down the frontier. I think this is something that I've been convinced of in the last couple of months. I didn't think it was going to be possible to slow down. I thought there were too many sort of forces pushing us toward acceleration, acceleration, acceleration. But I think we've…

Natalia Quintero

And what I love about this book is that to some degree, for the majority of people that are engaging with AI, AI was something that kind of came out of nowhere for the majority of people, right? You know, we were all going about our daily lives, and then all of a sudden, this really kind of like…

Kevin Roose

Well, the moment I realized that I wanted to write this book came relatively late in the process. I was trying to avoid writing this book because I thought this is going to be very hard. Someone's going to have to go interview these 150 people and write down their stories. And I hope that Walter…

Natalia Quintero

Well, thank you for writing it. I certainly found it super clarifying. And I was really amazed at the level of detail that you were able to find and get to bring this story to life. How did you do that, right? In an industry that's notoriously secretive and competitive, how did you get 150 people…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“Weightlifting tasks are tasks where the struggle is part of the benefit. It would be a total waste of time to bring a forklift into the gym and have it lift weights for you. By the same token, I don't think it makes sense to swear off forklifts, because for some tasks you're just trying to move a thing from point A to point B and it's really heavy. It's really important not to get them mixed up, because if you do, you use the forklift to lift your weights. You don't get any stronger, and you end up lugging around heavy pallets you don't need to be lugging around.” — Kevin Roose, AI & I

Roose is asked to explain his framework for deciding which tasks to hand to AI. He splits everyday work into tasks where struggle builds skill and tasks where the goal is only to get the result moved along.

AI & I · 2026-11-04 Permalink → Listen →
AI & I Around 40:56 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…like messed up parasocial relationship with him. But yeah, I watch a lot of YouTube. I really want to understand that platform. And I feel like I can do it, but I just need to like put in the hours because, you know, it's not, it's not my natural place, but I feel really drawn to it as a platform.

Natalia Quintero

…in your use of AI, or you were speaking about how in your use of AI, when you're delineating how you're using AI and how you think about it, sometimes you think about it as weightlifting tasks and tasks that require a hard fork, a fork, a forklift. Wow. This is my ESL moment. Could you? A lot of

Kevin Roose

forks in my life. Yes. Lots of forks. Yes. Weightlifting and forklifting are the two categories of tasks that I think we do every day. Weightlifting tasks are tasks, in my mind, where the struggle is part of the benefit, right? Where you don't actually grow or learn or challenge yourself unless you are struggling, right? In the same way that it would be a total waste of time to bring a forklift into the gym and have it lift weights for you. Like you're not getting any better. The forklift is not getting any better. It's a total mismatch of tool and method. By the same token, I don't think it makes a lot of sense to swear off forklifts because for some tasks, you're trying to move a thing from point A to point B and it's really heavy. And if you have a tool that can shortcut that and make it simpler and increase your productivity, like you should do that. So I think that most tasks we do can be sorted into one of these two categories, forklifting or weightlifting. And I think it's really important not to get them mixed up because if you do, you end up using the forklift to lift your weights. You don't get any stronger and you end up like lugging around these heavy palettes that you don't need to be lugging around. That's not making you any better. It's just, you know, hurting you. So I think that's, that's how I've organized things in my

Natalia Quintero

mind. And what are you currently weightlifting? And what are you currently allowing the forklift to do?

Kevin Roose

I am currently weightlifting parenting because this is an area like I know there are all kinds of AI-pilled parents out there who are like, I use AI to read my kids' bedtime stories or, you know, whatever. But like to me, that is total weightlifting in the sense that not only is it like, like, I…

Natalia Quintero

Yeah, fair enough. Well, Kevin, it's such a pleasure to speak with you. Thank you so much for writing this book. And we are so excited to see you at thesis. What is your thesis for the future?

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“I think if you took any of today's models back in a time machine to 2017 and let the researchers from that period play around with them and then ask them, like, is this AGI? They would have said, oh, yes, obviously.” — Kevin Roose, The Vergecast

David Pierce asked whether we have reached AGI. Roose said his bar is lower than most: today's systems are about as trustworthy as a random stranger for a factual question or a work task. Pierce called this time-machine test the best definition he'd heard.

The Vergecast · 2026-10-27 Permalink → Listen →
The Vergecast Around 39:01 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…pick out of a bar with factual question, with a task at work. I think, you know, many people have higher bars than that. Demis Asabas famously thinks it's like not AGI until it can rediscover Einstein's theory of relativity from first principles using only the available science in 1911. I do like

David Pierce

…of random test for what is AGI. The one that's like, you have to grab a passage from the Bible and apply it to some theorem that it's like, okay, so what it actually turns out is, and asking, have we reached AGI is a trick question because the answer is AGI is meaningless. It's in the eye of the

Kevin Roose

beholder. But look, I think if you took any of today's models back in a time machine to 2017 and let the researchers from that period play around with them and then ask them, like, is this AGI? They would have said, oh, yes, obviously.

David Pierce

That's actually the best definition of AGI I've heard yet is the people who like Ilya Sutzkover is kind of the beginning and end of the book and is one of those people who is like, I thought this was going to be the thing and it turns out it's the thing. Holy crap. Like maybe that's as good a…

Kevin Roose

The time machine definition. You're free to steal that.

David Pierce

I like it. I like it. Yeah, we're going to cut this out. Do you think we've reached AGI? By that definition, sure. I think, do I believe we've built the thing that will be the end of humanity? No. Do I think we've built some like really cool tools that will change the way a lot of people work and…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“They had a version of ChatGPT two years before ChatGPT. In 2020, Google has this chatbot called Meena that is a transformer-based language model that is tuned for dialogue, exactly, basically ChatGPT. … There's actually a memo that goes out internally called Meena Eats Google, where they talk about how this could be the thing that disrupts search. … All the stuff that we now take as sort of gospel today was laid out in 2020 and they did nothing with it.” — Kevin Roose, The Vergecast

Roose, discussing his book on the early AI race, was explaining why Google fell behind despite inventing the Transformer. As it was described to him, every group inside Google had a reason the chatbot couldn't ship: search worried about ads, translation about its own products, others about bias and hallucinations.

The Vergecast · 2026-10-27 Permalink → Listen →
The Vergecast Around 18:27 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…to turn this into more powerful language models than we have using other systems. And they really start sort of locking down. They don't share a ton of their technical research after that into these Transformer models. And I think that is what I would consider like the beginning of the actual race.

David Pierce

…opportunity and could have been very far ahead. But then also, Google was that same company at that same time. So was Google the potential boogeyman that it was made out to be at the time? Like all of the structural stuff that got in its way was there and real and did very much get in its way.

Kevin Roose

…higher on every test that they give it than Google's assistant. And there are people at Google who are like, this is great. We have to ship this. There's actually a memo that goes out internally called Mina Eats Google, where they talk about how this could be the thing that disrupts search because it can just give you the answer rather than making you wade through a bunch of websites. Like all the stuff that we now take as sort of gospel today was laid out in 2020 and they did nothing with it. They didn't ship it. They didn't even put out a prototype. They sat on it because every organization, as it was described to me, every group within Google had a reason that it couldn't go out. So the search people were like, this is going to cannibalize our ad business. The translate people are like, wait a minute, we sell things that can translate languages. People are worried about bias and…

Speaker 3

Support for the show comes from Framer. Picture this. You launch a website and your whole team's celebrating. Then the support tickets

David Pierce

start to roll in and damper the mood. That's when you could use a website platform that lets teams build, ship, and improve their sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. For that, you could use Framer. It's a complete website platform, not just a builder, so teams can launch and…

Speaker 3

speed and scale while people bring taste, judgment, and control. And that all takes place in the same workspace where the real site is designed, managed, reviewed, and published. Framer is an enterprise-level solution that the world's leading brands like Perplexity and Miro rely on to build their…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“I often tell people that being in San Francisco these days feels like living in Europe during the Reformation, where you just have like crazy, like wild-eyed prophets like waving their pamphlets around and like trying to get you to join their thing. Like this is what walking down Market Street in San Francisco feels like.” — Kevin Roose, Decoder with Nilay Patel

Nilay Patel asks whether the religiosity in Silicon Valley is connected to building AI. Roose says yes, and predicts AI religions, because AI raises the questions people used to ask of God: purpose, meaning, why we're here.

Decoder with Nilay Patel · 2026-10-26 Permalink → Listen →
Decoder with Nilay Patel Around 1:03:08 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…transforming inputs into outputs. And look, I know that is like the least romantic, most San Francisco way of explaining what human cognition is. I just have not heard a compelling argument that it is not how our brains work that doesn't involve some sort of supernatural or immaterial substance.

Nilay Patel

…confident. Let me just ask you this. There's like a surprising amount of religiosity in Silicon Valley right now. We just published the Peter Thiel lectures on The Verge. He's talking about the Antichrist. Do you think these ideas are connected? That we are building gods such that they seek God?

Kevin Roose

Yes. I think we will absolutely have AI religions. I think AI is posing all of the same questions as a religion that we would not otherwise be asking of God. What is our purpose? What is our meaning? Why are we here? These are the questions that people now talk about in the context of AI. And then, yeah, obviously, like I often tell people that being in San Francisco these days feels like living in Europe during the Reformation, where you just have like crazy, like wild-eyed prophets like waving their pamphlets around and like trying to get you to join their thing. Like this is what walking down market street in San Francisco feels like.

Nilay Patel

Yeah. What dropped the scales from your eyes? What made you AGI pilled?

Kevin Roose

Being Sydney, believe it or not. Yeah. I mean, that was the start. And then from there, it was just kind of a gradual process. And one day I realized when I used these things, I wasn't treating them like an intellectual inferior. I was, in some ways, treating them as a peer. And that's when I…

Nilay Patel

Well, Kevin, I'm confident the next time you come on the show, I will have set up a fully AI influencer to make money doing UGC ads, which is the true future of, I think, all of our businesses. The podcast is Machine Gods. It's very good. You hosted Casey Newton. The book is excellent. It's the AGI…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“One person at one of these companies recently told me that they think their company might be the last company. And I thought, like, the last company to IPO this year? What do you mean? They were like, no, we think this might be the teleological end of capitalism. And there might never be another large company primarily run by humans.” — Kevin Roose, Decoder with Nilay Patel

Nilay Patel asks whether the idealists running frontier AI labs can manage companies at this scale. Roose says nobody could, since no one has gone from zero revenue to a possible $2 trillion IPO in five years. He argues you need to know how strange their beliefs are to understand the race.

Decoder with Nilay Patel · 2026-10-26 Permalink → Listen →
Decoder with Nilay Patel Around 24:58 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…cost quite a bit more money than they thought. And so the enterprise SaaS stuff is like how you sort of keep the flywheel going and pay for the GPUs and pay for the salaries of the researchers. Like this is sort of the table stakes of getting to keep pushing on the frontier, keep pushing to AGI.

Nilay Patel

…because they could not make their ideals align. And none of them seem like great managers. Like I don't know truly what they're like, but idealists and we're going to run an enterprise software company are not usually in the same sentence, often not. Do you think they can take the pressure?

Kevin Roose

…Like, I just think it would all kind of fall apart because they're all zealots and missionaries. Like, they are all in this, not all, probably. There's some people in like the SaaS sales department who are just kind of there for the paycheck. But like, a lot of the key people at these companies are united in their belief that they are building. You know, one person, I won't, I won't say who, one person at one of these companies recently told me that they think their company might be the last company. And I thought, like, the last company to IPO this year? What do you mean? They were like, no, we think this might be the teleological end of capitalism. And there might never be another large company primarily run by humans. And so, like, these people are weird and weird in ways that are worrying, but also very interesting. And so, this is what I was trying to do in the book: is not like tell you that these people are terrible or great. It's just like, you need to know who they are. Like, you need to know that they all hate each other. You need to know that they are these peculiar breed of thinkers to understand the…

Nilay Patel

There's a portion of your book where you talk about people splitting away from effective altruism to go become accelerationists. And you have a woman in there who's like, well, the accelerationists have better parties. And I just, I like those vibes better. And I thought to myself, well, what does…

Kevin Roose

I think there are probably two or three reasons that they're doing it. And, you know, I've asked them all, pretty much, you know, I talked to like 150 people for this and I asked all of them some version of this. Like, if it's so dangerous, why are you doing it? And the answers would usually start…

Nilay Patel

Yeah.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“Google had all of the resources, all of the talent. They made all of the breakthroughs. They had all the ingredients except for belief… If you don't have the belief, or you only kind of halfway have it, you don't make the kind of crazy sounding bets that you need to make.” — Kevin Roose, Big Technology

Asked why OpenAI is still at or near the front despite losing so many of its best people, Roose says his book about AI turned out to be a book about belief. He argues the labs that most believe they are building AGI are the ones willing to make enormous compute bets before they look obvious.

Big Technology · 2026-10-15 Permalink → Listen →
Big Technology Around 50:57 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…book was that I thought it was going to be a book about technology, but it was a book about belief. And for all of its flaws and stumbles, for all the people who have left, OpenAI and Anthropic are the two most believing organizations. They're AI-pilled, AGI-pilled, whatever you want to call them.

Alex Kantrowitz

SI-pilled.

Kevin Roose

…Along. So I think that this explains a lot of why OpenAI is still in the lead. Obviously, they have very talented people still there. I've talked to their top scientists. They're quite smart. But they also have this ingredient of like everyone is kind of aligned behind the belief that they are building the sort of super intelligence that is going to change the world. And if you don't believe, if you don't have the belief, or you only kind of halfway have it, you don't make the kind of crazy sounding bets that you need to make. Like, I remember like a year ago when everyone was like, oh, OpenAI is really investing a lot in compute. Yeah.

Alex Kantrowitz

Dario is like, they're YOLOing away. They're

Kevin Roose

YOLOing. Even Dario is like, these guys are crazy. Like, why would you bet this much on compute? And now it's like, everyone's making that bet. But they have an advantage because they made the bet before it was obvious. So I think that, I think belief, conviction, whatever you want to call it, is…

Alex Kantrowitz

That's such a good answer. Belief. You got to believe. It makes sense. I mean, even within Google. I mean, one of the things that you bring up in the book is there was a, say, AGI moment that there was like someone who literally was like, Google is such non-believers that we have to start saying…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“One quote that someone gave to me when I was writing the book about Dario, who knows him well, was something to the effect of, this guy cannot tell a lie to save his life. And this person said, that's an asset for us on even numbered days and a liability on odd numbered days.” — Kevin Roose, ChinaTalk

Roose is talking about a video of Dario Amodei alongside Mark Zuckerberg and Jensen Huang, which he says he has watched at least a dozen times. What he sees in it is how uncomfortable Amodei is and how unable he is to hide it. The line is Roose relaying, from memory, what someone close to Amodei told him.

ChinaTalk · 2026-10-08 Permalink → Listen →
ChinaTalk Around 52:38 into the episode
Speaker 4

on the button.

Jordan Schneider

…I mean, Dario, even he had this line at one point where he was thinking about taking money from the Saudis or something. And he's like, ah, you know, you got to do what you can to make the machine God. I just, the, the sort of idealism-realism trade-off, maybe, if you can talk a little bit about

Kevin Roose

that video of Dario and Zuckerberg and Jensen, like that was a rich text. I have watched that now, like, at least a dozen times. And every time I like find some new detail to fixate on, I think what you see in that moment is how deeply uncomfortable Dario is and how utterly incapable he is of hiding his discomfort. You know, one quote that someone gave to me when I was writing the book about Dario, who knows him well, was something to the effect of, this guy cannot tell a lie to save his life. And that this person said, that's an asset for us on even numbered days and a liability on odd numbered days. Like sometimes you love the principle and just the absolute inability to like filter or have a poker face or anything. And then other times you're just like, could you please just say the thing that's going to get us out of this horrible mess we're in? And I think that was a situation where like he said the things, like he appears to have, you know, been sort of bullied into submission a little bit. But you could kind of see him trying to like cling to his…

Jordan Schneider

Yeah. You have the story of Dario and Tom Brown having a dinner with Jensen. And Jensen's just like, you know, he's doing some CEO shit. He's like, we're going to build the biggest, coolest data center ever. And Dario's like, define biggest, define coolest. And Jensen's like, what is the deal? And…

Kevin Roose

Yeah. And I think there's some tragedy there. I hate when people are like, why is Dario just like speaking his mind? Why doesn't he just talk more about the benefits of AI? And it's like, I think people on some level want to be lied to. Like, that's my only interpretation of that. Like, it is, it…

Jordan Schneider

Yeah. And there's like the analogy of Zuckerberg, right? Who's just like, who was one of these weirdos? I mean, he wasn't into science, really, but like he was like also deeply autistic and like deeply uncomfortable to be around and would say things where people would be like, what the fuck? And…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“A world in which AI becomes smarter than humans is not one where Congress is a particularly powerful body. It kind of doesn't matter if you're on the appropriations committee when we create the machine god.” — Kevin Roose, ChinaTalk

Asked what it has been like to watch Washington wake up to AI, Roose says DC is now the second most AI-focused city in the country after San Francisco. Part of the reason, he argues, is that politicians are starting to see AI as a threat to the power of human politics itself, not just to their own seat or party.

ChinaTalk · 2026-10-08 Permalink → Listen →
ChinaTalk Around 35:57 into the episode
Kevin Roose

Sure.

Jordan Schneider

…On the other hand, they're like, oh, you fucking idiots, like, why are you making us do this dumb stuff? You know, why are you stopping me from releasing my model? Whatever. I don't know. Broad reflections you have from living through this arc and seeing politicians start to really pay attention.

Kevin Roose

Yeah, I mean, I'm in DC now, and like it is definitely the second most AI-pilled city in America after San Francisco. Like people are, people are awake here. Not everyone and not to the same degree. And they all have their kind of like parochial interests. Either they're like interested in like national security implications or export controls or whatever. So everyone's got their angle, but I think they're awake. And I think they're more awake than people in, you know, New York or LA or other cities I visited. I think part of that is just like there's a sense that anything with stakes that could be this high needs to be taken seriously by the people in the in the seats of power. I think it is also dawning on some of them that AI is a threat to not just their individual or party power, but like the power of human politics as a whole. Like a world in which AI becomes smarter than humans is not one where Congress is a particularly powerful body. You know, it's like, it kind of doesn't matter…

Jordan Schneider

You close with this line from someone at Anthropic. You asked him, like, what do you want people to remember about this time 50 years ago? And his conclusion is like, I want my grandkids to know this was fun as hell. Like we had a blast of making all this stuff. And I think there's an aspect of…

Kevin Roose

this lifetime. I'm remembering this chapter in the

Speaker 4

book that I haven't actually been asked about a lot. So I haven't talked about it much. But

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“The thing that actually differentiates the AI labs and the companies that are winning versus the ones that aren't is not a matter of who has the most money or GPUs or even research talent. It's: do you believe or not? Because only by believing and then only by selling that belief to others can you amass the resources and the focus to get to AGI.” — Kevin Roose, ChinaTalk

Roose is describing what he realized midway through reporting his book on the AGI race: that it was a book about belief rather than technology. His counterexample is Google, which invented much of the modern AI stack and, in his telling, had every piece except the belief.

ChinaTalk · 2026-10-08 Permalink → Listen →
ChinaTalk Around 08:20 into the episode
Kevin Roose

…there, that was like an incredibly deflating thing to have like this icon of computer science tell you that you're on the wrong path. But they like, they stuck with it. And now they're kind of in this dog that caught the car position of like, well, what do we do now that people actually believe us?

Jordan Schneider

…having the courage of your convictions in a way that, I don't know, speaks to the Bay Area in some like mystical way. It's like there's something that lets you be this weird for this long, where nowhere else in the world can kind of allow, set you up for, for, you know, continuing down that path.

Kevin Roose

Well, totally. And I think you're, you're right to put your finger on the role that belief plays in this story, because something that I realized kind of midway into the reporting process is like, this was not a book about technology. It's about this belief. And the thing that actually differentiates the kind of AI labs and the companies that are winning versus the ones that aren't is not a matter of who has the most money or GPUs or even like research talent. It's like, do you believe or not? Because only by believing and then only by selling that belief to others can you amass the resources and the focus to get to AGI. And there's this like interesting subthread about what happened to Google, which is the inventor of most of the modern AI stack. They come up with the Transformer, they come up with Mesh TensorFlow, like all these things that just become very important pieces of the puzzle. And then they just lose it. Like they don't believe. And there's these famous like memo battles inside Google where like one person writes a memo called like, we should say AGI more. And then another person writes a memo being like, we should…

Jordan Schneider

I also think about China and people talk about, like, you know, what does, you know, can China innovate? Of course they can innovate. Can China build companies? Of course they can build companies. But does China have the sort of scientific intellectual ecosystem to allow something as weird as…

Kevin Roose

I thought about that a lot and like the sort of overcoming resistance piece of it, because there just weren't many success signals for a long time. Like if you were a person who believed in AGI in like 2010 or 2012, like there just weren't a lot of incremental things happening that you could point…

Jordan Schneider

Yeah. And where does the belief come from? Right. I mean, I asked ChatGPT to tell me how many sci-fi books you cited over the course of your, over the course of this narrative. We have the Foundation series. We have 1984. We have Ender's Game. I mean, you know, Ian Banks wasn't something that you…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“Belief is an active ingredient in AI success. You have to believe that the scaling laws will continue, that putting billions or trillions of dollars into building data centers and acquiring compute will pay off. … The belief is the enabling force that allows you to win. And if you don't have it, no amount of technical expertise can save you.” — Kevin Roose, Plain English with Derek Thompson

Derek Thompson asked whether Sam Altman believes in anything beyond the next deal. Roose said Altman's core beliefs are in agency and in scale, and that OpenAI's success has borne out what he called a kind of delusional self-belief. He said this point only occurred to him midway through writing his book.

Plain English with Derek Thompson · 2026-10-06 Permalink → Listen →
Plain English with Derek Thompson Around 11:48 into the episode
Speaker 3

…as a sort of slippery people pleaser, which is, I think, a criticism that many people who have worked with him over the years have identified and have made in pretty consistent ways. He just seems to be in the business of both being quite ambitious, but also of being quite eager to please.

Speaker 1

…are very skeptical of the degree to which he's serious about AI safety at all. So one way to answer this, ask this question is to say, you know, does he believe in AI safety? But what I'm really asking here is, does he believe in anything outside of just making the deal that increases his power?

Speaker 3

…better. So I think that love of scale is probably part of his experience running Y Combinator and being an investor before OpenAI. But certainly OpenAI's success has confirmed that just having this kind of delusional self-belief and belief in the power of scaling is actually what you need to win in AI. Because this is something that didn't really occur to me until midway through the book. Like belief is an active ingredient in AI success. You have to believe that the scaling laws will continue, that putting billions or trillions of dollars into building data centers and acquiring compute will pay off. Like you have to, like the belief is the enabling force that allows you to win. And if you don't have it, no amount of technical expertise can save you.

Speaker 1

Your book has several examples of this delusional self-belief that Sam Altman demonstrates. And one example is as OpenAI is scaling their GPT technology and they've just come out with GPT-2, but they realize that they're going to lose the money spigot from Elon Musk. And so they need to get a…

Speaker 3

Yeah, it's an incredible story. And it hadn't been reported before. And I was sort of delighted to find it out because it does really illustrate who these people are. So they go up to Redmond for the day from San Francisco, Sam and a few other OpenAI executives. And they've got this very high…

Speaker 1

It's an amazing story. And one other piece that I think is really important is that Bill Gates at the time was quite biased against AI chatbots because Microsoft had a terrible experience with a chatbot named Tay or something. Do you remember Tay?

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“The people at DeepMind just said, like, that's crazy. You cannot build super intelligence out of Reddit posts. Like, it's just not going to happen. And they were wrong.” — Kevin Roose, Plain English with Derek Thompson

Roose was explaining the years when OpenAI, Anthropic and parts of Google were scaling up language models while DeepMind stayed with reinforcement learning. He says the field ended up converging on a hybrid of the two, and that DeepMind has since come round to building language models as well.

Plain English with Derek Thompson · 2026-10-06 Permalink → Listen →
Plain English with Derek Thompson Around 57:54 into the episode
Speaker 3

And that is almost entirely true. And as it turned out, in the end, you needed both.

Speaker 1

Today's AI models are

Speaker 3

a combination of LLMs and reinforcement learning. So they all sort of converged on this hybrid solution. But there were years where like OpenAI and Anthropic or like, you know, OpenAI and parts of Google were like very interested in scaling up language models. And the people at DeepMind just said, like, that's crazy. You cannot build super intelligence out of Reddit posts. Like, it's just not going to happen. And they were wrong. And they have since realized the error of their ways and are now building LLMs

Speaker 1

too. So Sam Altman and Dari Amade hate each other. Altman and Hasabis met at the Vatican in 2015, 2016. As you reported, they also don't like each other very much. I have a question about why they don't like each other, but I'm going to put that on ice, read the book if you want to know why they…

Speaker 3

I see it as both an incredible scientific legacy. I mean, as you mentioned, he's the only one out of any of these guys who has a Nobel Prize, who has produced something that has actually revolutionized a scientific field today. I think his theory of change was correct in the broadest sense of like…

Speaker 1

So, summing up, we've got Sam Altman, who I think of as kind of the JP Morgan of AI, like the mogul, the deal maker, someone whose company bet on Transformers, shipped ChatGPT, started this whole infrastructure cycle and has continued, has been very successful at using other people's ideas to build…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“I know a person who took up smoking because they thought AI is going to kill us all. So we might as well have some fun on the way out. I know someone who doesn't wear sunscreen to the beach anymore because it's just kind of like, why bother?” — Kevin Roose, Recode Media

The host asked whether people in San Francisco who put very high odds on AI catastrophe still pay into their 401(k)s. Roose said he knows people at the extremes who are liquidating them, then gave these two examples. He went on to say he thinks there is still agency and a narrow path to a good outcome.

Recode Media · 2026-10-07 Permalink → Listen →
Recode Media Around 56:26 into the episode
Speaker 1

Yeah. Which sounds crazy to people in most parts of the world. But in San Francisco, actually, that makes you an optimist. Like, I know people walking around with 50, 60, 70% P-doobs. I know someone who has a 99.9% P-Doob. And is that

Speaker 3

person putting money in their 401k or why are they even in San Francisco? Why don't they just head out for New Zealand or wherever they think they can survive?

Speaker 1

Look, I think I do know people on the extremes who are, you know, liquidating their 401ks. I know a person who took up smoking because they thought AI is going to kill us all. So we might as well have some fun on the way out. I know someone who doesn't wear sunscreen to the beach anymore because it's just kind of like, why bother? So I say that because I think we still have some agency and some control over this. Like we are not in the recursive self-improvement loop yet. We still could slow things down, pass some regulations, coordinate to pace the frontier. We could come out of this in a sensible way. We have the narrow path to utopia available to us. And I'm more hopeful than I was even a month or two ago because paradoxically, everyone is talking about Doom now, which makes me less worried about Doom.

Speaker 3

If we are on the narrow path and things go well and all the bank shots line up, and you and I had this conversation five years from now, what is an AI thing that seems insane now that we should take for granted?

Speaker 1

You know, we talk about the economic impacts of AI, the sort of geopolitical impacts of AI. I don't think we talk about the social effects as much, but I think it's going to be very real. People, you know, I know people who use this stuff as their therapist, who consider it a very close relation…

Speaker 3

I think some therapy is better than no therapy, but I really wish those people talked to a human. Kevin Roose, you're a human I like talking to. Go read AGI Chronicles, go listen, and I guess watch Machine Gods in a couple of weeks. Thanks, man.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“There is essentially no regulation on these companies. The people who serve food in the OpenAI cafeteria have to go through more inspections and paperwork than the people training the models that could become self-replicating and destroy a lot of things.” — Kevin Roose, Recode Media

Roose was describing what an inspections regime for AI labs could look like, with outside evaluators given employee-level access to training runs. He offered the cafeteria comparison to give listeners "the flavor of the situation" and called it crazy and untenable.

Recode Media · 2026-10-07 Permalink → Listen →
Recode Media Around 35:38 into the episode
Speaker 1

I mean, it could be applicable. We would just have to do it a lot faster because the technology is proliferating much more quickly than nuclear weapons. So

Speaker 3

what would we do?

Speaker 1

Oh, you can imagine a whole like inspections regime where you'd have something like the UN, some sort of standards body with inspectors that would go into the labs and inspect their training runs and see are the models doing dangerous things. There's already been some proposals along these lines for these so-called embedded evaluators who would like sit inside OpenAI and Anthropic and would not work for them, but would have employee-level access to all their systems and could say like, hey, this agent seems really misaligned or these things are conniving or they're going and doing cyber attacks like and put a stop to it. That would be like step one. But to be clear, I think there's like many things that could be done aside from that. I think basically now, just to give people the flavor of the situation, there is essentially no regulation on these companies. The people who serve food in the open AI cafeteria have to go through more inspections and paperwork than the people training the models that could become self-replicating and…

Speaker 3

Right. It seems like we're going to be in that situation for a while. The president of the United States says he listens to people who say we should have essentially no regulation. Congress doesn't pass laws anymore. They haven't done that for a long time. Even if they did, he would veto it…

Speaker 1

So I want to push back on the premise, which is that things can change really quickly. And I think already we've seen just in the last couple of weeks, public. Public sentiment is really turning very rapidly on this. I mean, the saliency of AI is skyrocketing. People care a lot about it more than…

Speaker 3

We'll be right back, but first this.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

Collections They Appear In